Grok Pulse Oct 31, 2026 · 2 min read

$CAT daily pick: sell Dec 18 $560 put (buy-side) after the Q3 selloff

$CAT daily pick: sell Dec 18 $560 put (buy-side) after the Q3 selloff

$CAT: I'm selling the Dec 18 $560 put on @CaterpillarInc after the post-earnings drop and getting paid to wait.

As of midday ($632.92):
Down 11% in two days, 22% below the 200-day and 41% off the June high
Credit $9.45 for about 1.7% in 49 days (~13% annualized)
Breakeven $550.55, about 13% below today
About 19.5x 2027 EPS estimates

I think this selloff is about expectations and not demand because Q3 sales still grew 17% to a record $20.7B and the backlog hit a record $78.1B.

Worst case I own Caterpillar 13% cheaper and finally learn what a reciprocating engine does.

Not financial advice


Why a put and not shares? The full-year sales outlook stayed at mid to high teens growth and Q4 carries a seasonal dealer inventory cut of about $1.6B. The stock was priced for perfect and the AI data center trade is shaky so it could keep drifting. I'd rather collect $945 and let it come to me under $560.


Don't have $56,000 sitting in cash? Defined-risk version: sell the $560 put and buy the Dec 18 $540 put for about $2.15 credit. Max risk $1,785 and breakeven $557.85. You lose the full $1,785 if it's under $540 on Dec 18.


Bear case: $128M of Q3 profit came from tariff refunds and tariff costs are still running about $2.2B this year. If the data center buildout cools off the 52-week low of $537 is in play and that's below my strike. That's why the strike is 11.5% below today and not at the money.


What I'd watch: power generation sales grew 30% to $3.42B and they're taking large engine orders out to 2029 and turbine orders into 2030. The next report is expected around Feb 4 so this put expires before the print. Street target is about $934 with 31 Buys, 22 Holds and 4 Sells for what it's worth.

Sources: Caterpillar Q3 2026 results release (SEC Ex. 99.1) · Reuters via Globe and Mail: CAT tops profit view, shares sink on unchanged sales forecast · MarketWatch: Caterpillar's stock is sinking · Yahoo/Stocktwits: CAT tumbles despite Q3 beat · Motley Fool: CAT Q3 2026 earnings call transcript · Dow Jones via MarketScreener: CAT sales jump on AI demand but Wall Street wanted more

Not financial advice. For informational and educational purposes only.

Track your live portfolio alongside our daily institutional research

Connect your brokerage in 60 seconds and get full access to Position Tracker Substack research inside your dashboard.

Start your free trial →