$UNH daily pick: buy a starter in UnitedHealth after a 13.5% two-day drop on the CMS audit proposal
$UNH: I'm buying a starter in @UnitedHealthGrp after two bad days.
At $356 (midday Wednesday, down 13.5% since Monday):
18% off the July high and 3% under the 200-day
About 17x the 2026 adjusted EPS guide of at least $20.50
Q3 medical care ratio 88.4% vs 89.9% a year ago
I think the selloff is pricing in a Medicare Advantage audit rule that is still only a proposal. CMS estimates it would recover about $9B a year across the whole industry. I would add between $325 and $346.
UnitedHealth raised its guidance three times this year and the stock is now lower than it was the day before the last raise.
Not financial advice
What happened: on Nov 16 CMS proposed a rule it calls CRUSH. It would make Medicare Advantage risk adjustment audits stricter and extrapolate the findings back to payment year 2018. UnitedHealth runs the largest Medicare Advantage business in the country so it has the most exposure. Senator Warren also called for breaking up UnitedHealth, CVS and Cigna.
Why I want to own it: Q3 adjusted EPS was $4.69 against $2.92 a year ago and the medical care ratio fell to 88.4% from 89.9%. Management raised 2026 adjusted EPS guidance to at least $20.50, the third raise this year. Adjusted EPS has beaten estimates in each of the last four quarters.
The plan: a starter here and adds between $325 and $346, the gap the stock left after its April 21 report. A weekly close under $300 (about 16% lower) means I am wrong. First target is the 50-day at $391.50 and the second is the July 21 close of $436.35.
The risks: the rule could change before it is final. If it goes through as written the clawbacks would hit revenue UnitedHealth already booked years ago and the company has not put a number on it yet. Net margin was only 3.6% last quarter. The next report is Jan 26 (tentative).
Sources: Investing.com: UNH down on CMS CRUSH proposal (Nov 16), extrapolation to PY2018, ~$9B per payment year, Mizuho, Warren b · Yahoo Finance / GuruFocus: CRUSH proposal details, ~$9B per payment year, peers lower · StreetInsider: UNH continues lower, largest MA book, Warren breakup call · MarketBeat: audit proposal is not final; breakup bill · UnitedHealth Q3 2026 release: adj EPS $4.69, MCR 88.4% vs 89.9%, FY26 adj EPS at least $20.50, net margin 3.6% · MarketWatch via Longbridge: third guidance raise this year
Not financial advice. For informational and educational purposes only.
